For slices of pie to pick-up order through our sister cafe Beard & Belly - HERE PIE STORE Specialty Pies (48 hours notice needed) from $44.00 Select Flavor Key Lime Coconut Key Lime Salted Caramel Whiskey Walnut Pecan Pumpkin Almond Joy Black Bottom Banana Lemon Blueberry Milwaukee Mud (pie of the month) Add To Cart Quiche *Available for Mother's day Weekend* (48 hours notice needed) $44.00 Select Flavor Bacon, Cheddar & Scallion Carmelized Onion, Mushroom, Spinach, Sun-dried Tomato & Swiss Add To Cart Mother's Day Pies for pickup 5/10 through 5/12 (48 hours notice required) from $41.00 Select Flavor Key Lime Chocolate Cream Banana Cream Whiskey Walnut Pecan Door County Cherry w/ Streusel Classic Apple w/ Streusel Add To Cart Classic Fruit Pies (48 hours notice needed) $41.00 Select Flavor Apple Cherry Blueberry Peach Cherry Apple Peach Blackberry Strawberry Rhubarb Add To Cart Classic Cream Pies (48 hours notice needed) $44.00 Select Flavor Banana Cream Caramel Banana Chai Chocolate Cream Coconut Cream Coffee Cookies and Cream Mint Chocolate Add To Cart Gratuity to the Bakeshop Team! from $5.00 Select TIP $5.00 $10.00 $15.00 $20.00 Add To Cart